In the film Crocodile Dundee, a mugger threatens Mick Dundee with a switchblade. Mick seems amused and then delivers his famous line “That’s not a knife. [pulls out a large bowie knife]. That’s a knife.” Much like Mick was amused by the switchblade, we’re amused by some of the lumens we’re seeing reported from "tactical" lights on the market.
While a knife is a knife, all knives are not created equal. The same can be said of lights. Lights, like knives, vary in size, quality, craftsmanship, etc. There are different kinds of knives and different kind of lumens. In lighting, this causes a problem because some light manufacturers "purposely" don't distinguish what kind of lumens they're stating.
A light's intensity is measured in lumens. More lumens means more light, which typically makes a light more attractive and valuable to end users. If light manufacturers manipulate lumens for their own advantage, it makes it hard for customers to accurately compare two lights and can cause some customers to get ripped off. We don't want you getting ripped off so here's a quick lesson on lumens.
|"This is a knife."|
There are two ways to express / quantify lumens:
Here's the best and simplest way we can explain Torch vs. Emitter lumens:
Emitter lumens are NOT what you get when you turn on the light.
Torch Lumens tell the truth about "what comes out of the device".
Why Does This Matter So Much (When Comparing Lights)?
Failure to disclose the specific type of lumens measured can lead to inaccurate comparisons.
Using Emitter Lumens instead of Torch Lumens, will make a cheaper flashlight look much better than it really is.
Example: FoxFury’s 220 Torch (OTF) lumen Rook MD1 Flashlights is actually brighter than a 280 Emitter (Bulb) Lumen flashlight.
THE TAKE-HOME LESSON
If you're unsure about what type of lumens a light manufacturer uses in its measurements, then ask.
If a flashlight seems like it's too good to be true, then it probably is.
In other words, don't expect BMW performance at a Yugo price.